Impossible Journey

The Fourth Man

An Impossible Journey Across the Border

PK had travelled to Pakistan to deliver a lecture on India’s education system. The discussion was being streamed live on YouTube.

Nobody could have imagined what would happen next.

I have no recollection of crossing the border. No airport, no immigration counter, no passport stamp. Yet somehow, I found myself inside a modest room somewhere in Pakistan.

Four people were there.

An elderly man with a long white beard sat upright in a wooden chair. A little boy stood beside him, watching everything with wide-eyed curiosity. A young man reclined on a bed, listening intently. The fourth man was the presenter, conducting the discussion.

PK was speaking about India’s transformation—its universities, technology, infrastructure, economic growth and educational opportunities.

The atmosphere was extraordinary.

The participants listened with disbelief. Their questions revealed genuine astonishment. Could India really have progressed so far? Could its educational institutions, industries and technology have developed to such an extent?

I joined the conversation midway, listened for a while and occasionally contributed.

Then, as inexplicably as I had arrived, I disappeared.

No farewell. No explanation.

I was back in India.

And I thought nothing more of it.

Until Google found me.

A few days later, a YouTube clip began circulating on social media.

It showed PK’s discussion in Pakistan.

And there I was.

Clearly visible. Sitting among the participants.

The video had already accumulated thousands of views. Beneath it, the participant count identified four people on screen.

I was one of them.

At first, it seemed amusing.

Then someone in my company recognised me.

“Sir, isn’t that you in Pakistan?”

Within hours, the clip was circulating and colleagues in overseas  began forwarding it.

The questions became increasingly uncomfortable.

“When did you visit Pakistan?”

“Was this an official visit?”

“Why didn’t anyone know?”

“And how did you get there?”

I could hardly explain something I didn’t understand myself.

The strangest discovery came when I watched the recording from the beginning.

I had missed the opening presentation.

It featured images of Mumbai’s crowded suburban trains, railway stations, and beautiful green surroundings outside what looked remarkably like my own office.

How had those images found their way into a presentation in Pakistan?

And why had I appeared precisely after that introduction?

I considered an explanation.

Perhaps I could say I had been travelling through Dubai. During transit, I had somehow taken an unexpected detour to Pakistan, attended the discussion and returned.

But that explanation created even more questions.

Where were the immigration records?

What about the airline manifests?

The passport stamps?

Had I crossed an international border illegally?

Had I unknowingly become part of something much larger?

What if Pakistan’s ISI became interested?

Or India’s RAW?

An Indian business executive mysteriously appearing in a televised discussion in Pakistan, with no apparent record of entering or leaving the country, was hardly an everyday occurrence.

A colleague jokingly suggested that I should expect a telephone call from an intelligence agency.

I laughed.

But the laughter didn’t last.

Because the YouTube recording contained something even more disturbing.

I watched it again, frame by frame.

At one point, the elderly bearded man turned towards me and asked a question.

I remembered that moment perfectly.

I remembered my answer.

But when I replayed the recording, I heard myself say something I had no recollection of saying:

“Not every journey requires a passport.”

I froze.

Then I checked my phone.

On the day of the broadcast, my calendar showed that I had attended a meeting in India at exactly the same time.

My colleagues confirmed it.

There were even photographs.

In one photograph, I was seated in the conference room in India.

In the YouTube recording, I was seated in Pakistan.

Same clothes. Same watch. Same unmistakable face.

Same time.

I stared at both images.

One of them had to be false.

Unless, of course, both were true.

That evening, the presenter uploaded another short clip.

Its title was simple:

“The Mystery of Our Fourth Guest.”

I clicked on it.

The elderly bearded man was speaking.

“We never invited him,” he said quietly. “We don’t know how he entered the room.”

Then the little boy interrupted.

“But I know where he came from.”

Everyone turned towards him.

The boy pointed towards the camera.

“He came from the railway station in Mumbai.”

The recording ended.

I sat motionless, staring at the screen.

Because that morning, before the meeting in India, I had indeed passed through a Mumbai suburban railway station.

And for a fleeting moment, I remembered seeing an open door.

A door I had never seen before.

Perhaps I had walked through it.

Perhaps I hadn’t.

The real mystery was no longer how I had reached Pakistan.

It was whether I had ever left India at all.

DS 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

10cc gulp and 24 hour high

Rabbit and Tortoise story in Marathi musical

Madhav Julian and Indiver -प्रेमस्वरुप आई and Zindgi Ka Safar